Why Renting Still Makes Financial Sense for Tenants: Insights for UK Property Investors

UK property investors need to stay informed about the latest trends and data in today's dynamic property market. According to recent findings by Hamptons, would-be buyers with a 5% deposit face paying significantly more in mortgage repayments than if they continued renting. Here’s an in-depth look at why renting remains a financially sensible option and what it means for property investors.

Higher Mortgage Rates Impacting Buyers

Hamptons' research indicates that the average mortgage rate for buyers with a 5% deposit currently stands at 6.1%. This rate creates a considerable financial gap between renting and buying. Specifically, buying a home with a 5% deposit costs renters an additional £300 per month on average compared to renting. To balance the cost of renting and buying in Great Britain, mortgage rates must drop to around 4.2%.

Regional Variations in the Renting vs. Buying Cost

The financial disparity between renting and buying varies significantly across the UK:

1. Scotland and Northern England: In regions like the North West, North East, and Yorkshire & Humber, the cost difference between renting and buying with a 5% deposit is below £100 per month.
2. The Midlands: Here, the difference ranges from £117 to £122 per month.
3. Southern England: In the South West, an average first-time buyer pays £341 more per month to buy a home compared to renting. In London, this difference skyrockets to £775 per month, or £9,300 annually.


The Narrowing Gap and Its Implications

While the gap between renting and buying has narrowed since mortgage rates peaked last year, the current rates still pose a barrier for buyers with small deposits. In November 2022, the monthly cost difference was £547, but it has since reduced to £300. Despite this improvement, the high mortgage rates continue to make home purchases challenging, particularly in the more expensive southern regions.

Government Schemes and Their Effectiveness

Government initiatives like the mortgage guarantee scheme have attempted to boost 95% loan-to-value (LTV) lending. However, high interest rates have limited the scheme’s success. In 2023, mortgage guarantees were only 35% of the 2022 average, with completions far below those achieved by the Help to Buy scheme.

The effectiveness of these schemes largely depends on the Bank of England's interest rate decisions. Lowering rates would significantly impact the ability of buyers with small deposits to afford homes, more so than any government policy alone.

Rental Demand Remains Strong

Despite the rise in rental prices, renting remains more cost-effective for most households. This trend has kept rental demand high, particularly in regions where buying is less affordable. For property investors, this strong rental demand presents a lucrative opportunity. Investing in rental properties in regions with high rental demand and lower buying affordability can offer stable returns and long-term growth potential.


For UK property investors, the current market conditions highlight the advantages of focusing on rental properties. With higher mortgage rates making buying less viable, rental demand remains robust. Investors can benefit from these trends by strategically investing in rental properties, especially in regions where renting is significantly more affordable than buying.

At Magnate Assets, we provide comprehensive insights and updates on the UK property market to help you make informed investment decisions. Explore our latest property listings and market analyses to discover lucrative investment opportunities.

Stay tuned to our newsletter for the latest trends and expert insights into the ever-evolving real estate market.

Back to Blog

Related Articles

Anticipated Rental Increases Across the UK: A Boon for Property Investors

As property investors seek promising avenues for growth, Zero Deposit's analysis of historic rental...
Read More

Manchester Records Second Largest Increase in Rent Prices in UK

Manchester has the second largest increase in rent prices in the UK, behind Newbury. Recent data...
Read More

Tenant demand for UK Property Increases Significantly in the recent Quarter

In the final quarter of 2023, research conducted by Paragon Bank revealed that 60% of landlords...
Read More